HomeBlogWhy HR Managers Can’t Fix Bad Jobs
Human Resources Management

Why HR Managers Can’t Fix Bad Jobs

07 December 2022
This image shows a man leaning on his head, wearing glasses and a suit. His right hand is resting on his face, and his left arm is visible in a close-up. His tie is also visible in the foreground, and a white letter 'O' is visible in the background. In the top left corner of the image, a blurry image of a person's legs is visible. The man has a serious expression, and the lighting is warm and natural.
Reasons For Leaving a JobSigns and SymptomsPossible Mitigation Measures by HR
Unsustainable JobDiscrepancies in salary, toxic work environment, or unbearable work hoursImplementing structural change or dispute mediation might not always be possible
Goals MisalignmentOutgrowing the role, change in career aspirationsPossible role adjustment or promotion, but it may not coincide with company's needs or structure all the time
Lack of RecognitionNo feedback or appreciation for work, disrespectful coworkersHR could try to influence company culture, but might require top-level support
Toxic CultureBullying, harassment, or discrimination in the organisationEnforce stronger policies, but might struggle if issues are engrained or involve higher hierarchy
No career progressionNo opportunities for task variety, learning or promotionCould advocate for employee training and development, but limited by budget or management will
Poor managementErratic decision-making, unprofessional behavior from superiorsHR could mediate, but they may struggle if top management is the problem
Unfair treatmentInequity in workload, pay or benefitsAddress and redress, but scope might be limited
Lack of work-life balanceExcessive overtime, unrealistic deadlinesPromote healthy balance, but may be overruled by business needs
Job insecurityFrequent layoffs, company instabilityHR can provide information and support during difficult times, yet can't secure positions
Lack of trust in leadershipUnfulfilled promises, lack of transparencyHR can advocate for better communication, but can't control leadership actions

A nice Human Resources (HR) manager can make a world of difference for employees. But what happens when a job is bad—so bad that even the nicest of HR managers can’t fix it? How do you know when it's time to start looking for something new? Let’s explore why some jobs just aren’t salvageable and how to tell when you need to move on.

When the Job Is Unsustainable

Sometimes, there are certain aspects of a job that simply can't be fixed by an HR manager, no matter how nice they are. These could include salary discrepancies, a toxic work environment, or even long hours that don't align with your schedule. In cases like these, staying in the job is not only unsustainable but also potentially harmful.

When Your Goals Don't Align With Your Job

In other cases, your goals may no longer align with the job itself. This could mean you've outgrown the role or that your career aspirations have changed since you first accepted the job offer. It's important to remember here that your goals and ambitions should always come first—if they're not being met by this particular role then it might be time to consider moving on.

When You Don't Feel Valued

Feeling valued at work is essential for employee morale and productivity. If you don't feel like your work is being recognized or if feedback is lacking, then it's likely due to a lack of respect from management or co-workers alike. It's hard to stay motivated in this kind of environment and unfortunately, HR managers may not be able to change this dynamic without serious intervention from higher-ups in the company.

No matter how nice an HR manager is, sometimes bad jobs just can't be saved. Keep an eye out for signs such as unsustainable working conditions, lack of recognition for hard work done, or goals not being met within the company. If any of these signs pop up in your current workplace then it may be time to start looking elsewhere! After all, our career aspirations should always come first and taking care of ourselves means having the courage to move on when we need to.

Unsustainable Job, Discrepancies in salary, toxic work environment, or unbearable work hours, Implementing structural change or dispute mediation might not always be possible, Goals Misalignment, Outgrowing the role, change in career aspirations, Possible role adjustment or promotion, but it may not coincide with company's needs or structure all the time, Lack of Recognition, No feedback or appreciation for work, disrespectful coworkers, HR could try to influence company culture, but might require top-level support, Toxic Culture, Bullying, harassment, or discrimination in the organisation, Enforce stronger policies, but might struggle if issues are engrained or involve higher hierarchy, No career progression, No opportunities for task variety, learning or promotion, Could advocate for employee training and development, but limited by budget or management will, Poor management, Erratic decision-making, unprofessional behavior from superiors, HR could mediate, but they may struggle if top management is the problem, Unfair treatment, Inequity in workload, pay or benefits, Address and redress, but scope might be limited, Lack of work-life balance, Excessive overtime, unrealistic deadlines, Promote healthy balance, but may be overruled by business needs, Job insecurity, Frequent layoffs, company instability, HR can provide information and support during difficult times, yet can't secure positions, Lack of trust in leadership, Unfulfilled promises, lack of transparency, HR can advocate for better communication, but can't control leadership actions

In the realm of employment, a suitable HR manager with HR certification can significantly enhance a worker's experience. However, there are situations where job conditions are essentially beyond repair, even by the most proficient HR managers. These circumstances could encompass problematic pay scales, an unhealthy work environment, or excessive work hours that are incongruous with your lifestyle. It may also relate to a deviation between your personal ambitions and the job responsibilities or feeling undervalued in your role. Despite having a competent HR manager, the inability to rectify these issues may require the exploration of new job opportunities. Prioritizing personal goals and welfare in situations like these is essential, thus highlighting the significance of vigilance towards these negative signs at the workplace.hr certification

human resources hr management
A man with his hands held together in prayer or contemplation, his eyes closed and his head slightly bowed. He is wearing an expression of peacefulness and serenity, with a kind and gentle demeanor. His skin is a light brown, his hair is black, and he is wearing a white shirt and dark trousers. He stands in front of a plain white background, surrounded by a peaceful atmosphere. He appears to be deep in thought, reflecting on a meaningful issue. His posture conveys a sense of humbleness and respect.
Bilal Şentürk
Blogger

He completed his undergraduate studies at Celal Bayar University, Anadolu University and Istanbul University, and a Master's degree with thesis on Human Resources Management at Yıldız Technical University and Business Management at Beykent University. He is currently writing a doctoral thesis on human resources and consulting businesses on human resources.

Related Posts
Our team of experts is passionate about providing accurate and helpful information, and we're always updating our blog with new articles and videos. So if you're looking for reliable advice and informative content, be sure to check out our blog today.
This image shows a woman with dark curly hair, wearing a black shirt, and smiling. Her mouth is open and her teeth are showing. She has purple lipstick and a glowing complexion that stands out against her dark hair. In the background, there is a yellow and black sign with white text, and a black letter on a yellow background. There is also a close-up of the woman's neck, revealing her earrings. Her hair, which is curled and dark, is also featured in a close-up shot. The image is bright and vibrant, with an inviting and happy atmosphere.
Human Resources

What Is Human Resources Management?

02 December 2021
A man in a suit is sitting at a desk in front of a phone. He is wearing a blue shirt with a white collar and a white shirt underneath. He has a serious expression on his face as he talks on the phone. His hands are clasped together and he is holding a phone. In the background, a chair is visible with a close up of a hand holding a tablet. There is also a blurry image of a pen and a book. The man is focused on his conversation and is unaware of his surroundings.
Human Resources Management

What is a Human Resources Information System (HRIS)?

05 December 2022
A woman with shoulder-length brown hair is sitting at a table, wearing a black jacket and looking down at the book she is writing in. She has her eyes closed and appears to be deep in thought. On the table in front of her is a white letter 'O' on a black and brown background. To her left is an identical white letter on a black background, and to her right is another white letter 'O' on a black background. She is surrounded by a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Human Resources Management

Human Resources and Administration (HRA)

28 November 2022
A man in a suit sits at a desk, his right hand resting on his head. He looks deep in thought, a clock ticking on the wall behind him. In the foreground, a close-up of a black tie is visible. To the right, a coffee mug can be seen on the desk, and a white letter ‘O’ on a blue background is visible in the background. The man’s hands are close to a keyboard, and a watch can be seen near the top of the frame. He looks tired and frustrated, his brow furrowed and his eyes firmly closed.
Human Resources Management

5 Types of Employees that Hate Human Resources

13 November 2022
A group of people are sitting around a large round table. At the center of the table is a man in a suit, and to his right is a woman in a dress with a pen and a folder in her hands. On the wall behind them is a blurry clock. In the background, there is a white letter on a black background, a plant in a pot, and a close-up of a black lamp shade. A person is also seen sitting at a desk, and a plant can be seen in a white pot.
Human Resources Management

How to Get a Job as a Chief Human Resources Officer

01 November 2022
A man is smiling for the camera, wearing a plaid shirt and glasses. His eyes are closed, and a broad smile stretches across his face. He stands in front of a building, with a statue of a woman holding a staff just to the side. In the background a white letter 'O' is visible, appearing twice in the frame to the left of the man. His pose is relaxed, with his arms by his sides and one leg slightly bent. The image is a close-up, capturing the man's face in detail and highlighting his genuine expression of joy.
Human Resources Management

Earn Your Certificate in Human Resources Management Online

16 November 2022
This image shows a group of women standing with their arms crossed. The group consists of four people, one of whom is wearing a black jacket and white shirt with long hair. Another woman is wearing a suit and has her arms folded in front of her. In addition, there is a man in a suit standing in the background. In the foreground of the image, there is a white letter 'O' on a black background and a white letter on a brown surface. Additionally, there is another white letter on a grey background. All the people in the image have neutral expressions on their faces. The background of the image has an orange hue which creates a soft atmosphere.
Human Resources Management

10 Careers in Human Resources Management

04 November 2022